糖心Vlog

US bioethicist quits over censorship row at Northwestern University

Alice Dreger resigns her post after institution censored a 谤颈蝉辩耻茅 story in a medical journal

Published on
August 26, 2015
Last updated
February 16, 2017
Northwestern University

A leading US bioethicist has resigned her professorship in protest at censorship by university administrators.

In an explosive resignation letter on 24 August, Alice Dreger said that she could no longer work at Northwestern University鈥檚 Feinberg School of Medicine because of its ongoing intervention in the faculty-produced journal Atrium, which she has guest edited.

Dr Dreger, who held a professorship in clinical medicine humanities and bioethics, said that she had been appalled to hear that Atrium鈥檚 Bad Girls-themed had been withdrawn online at the behest of her dean Eric Neilson.

The edition had sparked controversy as it included a salacious account of a consensual sexual encounter between Syracuse University professor William J. Peace with a nurse in the 1970s, when he was an 18-year-old hospital patient.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

Peace, who had been paralysed, claimed that the sexual favour from a nurse had eased his worries about his ability to perform sexually in future. The journal was reinstated online 18 months after it was removed.

鈥淚聽could not believe my own dean would censor an article because it recounted a consensual blowjob between聽a nurse and a patient聽in 1978,鈥 said Dreger in her resignation letter, calling the episode a 鈥渃osmic joke鈥.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

She expressed her unease at the creation of what she called a 鈥渃ensorship committee鈥 for Atrium, which had been set up to monitor future content of the journal.

鈥淎n institution in which the faculty are afraid to offend the dean is not an institution where I can in good conscience do my work,鈥 wrote聽Dr Dreger in her addressed to Northwestern provost Daniel Linzer.

鈥淪uch an institution is not a 鈥榰niversity,鈥 in the truest sense of that word,鈥 she added.

Dr Dreger said that she could no longer do her work, particularly her research on academic freedom, given the ongoing censorship of Atrium, reported Torch, the publication produced by civil rights pressure group the .

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

鈥淰ague statements of commitment to the principle of academic freedom mean little when the institution鈥檚 apparent understanding of academic freedom in concrete circumstances means so little,鈥 wrote Dr Dreger.

Dr Dreger thanked Northwestern for its support on other matters of academic freedom, but said that she felt like an 鈥渁bject hypocrite鈥 for staying silent on the issue of Atrium.

However, the culture of the institution had changed and she felt that she no longer worked at an institution that 鈥渇earlessly defends academic freedom鈥n the face of criticism, controversy and calls for censorship鈥.

Dr Dreger has posted a list of about her resignation on her personal website.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

A spokesman for Northwestern University declined to comment in detail since it was 鈥渁 personnel matter鈥. 鈥淲e wish Professor Dreger well in her future endeavours,鈥 he added.

jack.grove@tesglobal.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT