糖心Vlog

Losing our place in the vanguard?

Senior figures worry that the UK is lagging behind the innovators and entrepreneurs pushing the frontiers of higher education

Published on
June 18, 2015
Last updated
June 18, 2015
John Gill, editor, 糖心Vlog
Source: Peter Searle

鈥淥ne of the most influential people in Silicon Valley鈥 announced that he was stepping down last week. But it wasn鈥檛 Twitter boss Dick Costolo, or another chino-clad princeling from Apple or Facebook, who was described in such exalted terms 鈥 it was John Hennessy, president of Stanford University.

鈥淣ormally, a university president stepping down isn鈥檛 a big deal in the world of business,鈥 the news website Business Insider explained, but Hennessy is different: 鈥溾. Those connections include directorships at Google and Cisco; and as Business Insider notes, many of the tech entrepreneurs who now shape the world aren鈥檛 just Stanford alumni, they also started their businesses while studying there.

Speaking to 糖心Vlog earlier this month, Steve Hilton, the former strategy adviser to David Cameron, described the 鈥profound effect鈥 of his stint as a visiting professor at Stanford (he is now a Silicon Valley-based tech entrepreneur 鈥 what else?).

Asked what lessons UK universities might learn from it, Hilton cited 鈥渁 much greater sense of openness鈥 and suggested that the UK鈥檚 universities were 鈥渢oo insular, too inward-looking鈥.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

This was a sweeping statement based more on observation than experience, he admitted, but there鈥檚 no getting away from comparisons between the US and the UK, and Hilton鈥檚 remarks chime with concerns raised by the former universities minister David Willetts in our cover story this week.

Reflecting on his years in government, he cites a frustration that many UK universities operate on the basis that 鈥渨e鈥檝e been around a long time, our job is to pass [this] on to the next generation much as it is now鈥. For Willetts, this was exemplified by the failure of any UK university to adopt the expansionist ambition shown by US-owned Laureate (which, incidentally, is reported to be planning a $1 billion initial public offering in 2016).

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

鈥淲e need some universities with an enterprise model 鈥 to recognise a fantastic opportunity to operate in five continents鈥o become a great British export,鈥 Willetts says. 鈥淚 had commercial investors saying to me that if British higher education came up with an investable proposition, they would put a billion into creating a global chain.鈥

Many will baulk at the suggestion that UK universities should emulate the world鈥檚 largest operator of for-profit colleges, but it shows the scale of what Willetts was hoping to achieve.

It鈥檚 interesting too that he chose the Laureate model, rather than Stanford鈥檚, as his example 鈥 perhaps because the UK has world-leading research universities, but what it doesn鈥檛 have is a higher education equivalent of Amazon or Google, with global reach and an aggressive online strategy.

罢丑别谤别鈥檚 evidence this week that some UK vice-chancellors also harbour concerns about a lack of innovation. An annual survey by PA Consulting Group suggests that some university leaders recognise that their institutions are 鈥渓agging behind鈥 in adopting new forms of flexible study and technology.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

That鈥檚 not to say that every university should or could seek to emulate the likes of Stanford or follow the route taken by even the most successful commercial players.

But it does pose a challenge. 鈥淚nnovation鈥 is an overused word, but ossification is not a strategy, and protecting universities 鈥 their values and traditions 鈥 is not the same as protecting the status quo.

john.gill@tesglobal.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT