In the days since it was revealed, the University of Austin has been widely dismissed as a collection of academic and political outcasts seeking to revive their professional images by crafting a paradise of free-speech fundamentalism.
But a closer look at the affiliations of leaders at the private liberal arts upstart, which is due to begin classes next autumn, suggests a more serious and strategic move by a group of wealthy donors looking to expand their already robust campaigns to stamp ideological agendas on to US campuses, some experts have warned.
鈥淲e can laugh at it now,鈥 said Isaac Kamola, assistant professor of political science at Trinity College who just听co-authored a book听examining Charles Koch and the myriad ways he and like-minded conservative philanthropists have infiltrated US higher education. 鈥淏ut I think we do so at our own peril.鈥
That is because Mr Koch and his allies have shown their ability to deploy billions of dollars in ever-expanding ways to shape student experiences, direct hiring and set research agendas.
糖心Vlog
If they succeed in creating their own university, Dr Kamola said, that control will grow even deeper, more partisan and more ideological.
Austin introduces itself as 鈥渁 university dedicated to the fearless pursuit of truth鈥, that revives face-to-face student debate in the tradition of Plato. 鈥淲e are done waiting for the legacy universities to right themselves,鈥 the project鈥檚 president, Pano Kanelos 鈥 the听recently resigned听head of St John鈥檚 College in Annapolis 鈥 declared in听. 鈥淎nd so we are building anew.鈥
糖心Vlog
Dr Kanelos touted a team of two dozen creators and advisers听that includes Lawrence Summers, former president of Harvard University. On 15 November the University of Chicago said that one of them, Robert Zimmer, its chancellor and former president, had , noting that Austin had 鈥渕ade a number of statements about higher education in general, largely quite critical, that diverged very significantly from my own views鈥. Professor Zimmer Steven Pinker, a professor of psychology at Harvard, prompting Austin to such advisers agreed 鈥渨ith all its actions and statements鈥.
Beyond those, the listed advisers and contributors include several academics and political figures with histories of being condemned for their words and actions, often related to their dismissal of the structural disadvantages in US society facing people who are not white and male. They include Joshua Katz, a professor of Classics who was suspended from Princeton University for a year for having an inappropriate relationship with a female undergraduate, and Peter Boghossian, a former assistant professor of philosophy at Portland State University听听after he was found to have committed research misconduct in his attempts to ridicule social scientists.听Another high-profile hire is Kathleen Stock, who recently left the University of Sussex as a result of ongoing controversy over her views on gender identity.
Several others on the list have ties to Mr Koch and his philanthropy, according to an analysis by Dr Kamola鈥檚 co-author, Ralph Wilson, a co-founder听and former research director at the advocacy group UnKoch My Campus now serving as听director of the Corporate Genome Project. They include people who have worked for Mr Koch or at academic centres or thinktanks he has funded, Mr Wilson said. The University of Austin also attributes its own initial funding to Cicero Research, part of a thinktank that largely shares Mr Koch鈥檚 libertarian-styled agenda.
Together, said Davarian Baldwin, professor of American studies at Trinity, the evidence suggests that the University of Austin is the new academic vanguard of political forces that have put heavy emphasis in recent years on confronting advocates of socio-economic progress and then claimed free speech victimhood when challenged.
糖心Vlog
It鈥檚 all part of a fiction, Professor Baldwin said, 鈥渢hat those who are actually in power听are in some way the victims听of some other kind of power鈥.
An Austin spokesman declined to explain whether or how the university would itself avoid political and donor influence in its operations; or why it was choosing a Chicago-based regional accrediting agency. The agency that usually covers Texas 鈥 the Southern Association of Colleges and Schools鈥 Commission on Colleges 鈥 recently听opened an investigation听into the University of Florida for banning its professors from countering the state鈥檚 Republican governor in a voting rights court case. With听its move, Austin is taking advantage of a Trump administration policy that听lets institutions pick accrediting agencies听outside their region.
The spokesman did, however, promise that Austin expected no limits on听academic expression. 鈥淲e believe a fundamental part of liberal education is engaging rigorously with radically alternative views and ideas,鈥 he said, 鈥渁s long as they abide by our university operating principles of open inquiry and civil discourse.鈥
Several experts said Austin could do far more to expand academic freedom through steps that include admitting more students from low-income and minority communities, and countering the nationwide trend toward hiring low-paid contingent instructors.
糖心Vlog
Such steps, said David Atkinson, associate professor of history at Purdue University, 鈥渨ould be a truly radical act in today鈥檚 higher education landscape鈥.
鈥淭he biggest challenges facing higher education,鈥 said Steven Mintz, professor of history at the University of Texas at Austin, 鈥渁re how to provide a far greater number of students with a rigorous, well-supported liberal education that promotes their well-rounded development.鈥
糖心Vlog
New institutions of higher education that truly improve intellectual diversity seemed rare, said Roopika Risam, associate professor of secondary and higher education and English at Salem State University. 鈥淭his is yet another straw man shot across the bows in the culture wars,鈥 Dr Risam said of the Austin project. 鈥淭here have been so few that have actually succeeded.鈥
POSTSCRIPT:
Print headline:听Dismiss University of Austin 鈥榓t own peril鈥
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to 罢贬贰鈥檚 university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?








