In 1974, clinical psychologist Dennis Upper of the Veterans Administration Hospital in Massachusetts, US, published in the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis the .
The tongue-in-cheek paper, titled 鈥淭he unsuccessful self-treatment of a case of 鈥榳riter鈥檚 block鈥欌, contained no words except the title, the author鈥檚 name and affiliation, one self-reference, and words of praise from one reviewer who examined the manuscript 鈥渧ery carefully with lemon juice and X-rays鈥.
You do not need to look too far for further examples of papers that get straight to the point.
When physicists found that neutrinos travelled faster than the speed of light, a claim that would break Einstein鈥檚 universal speed limit, Sir Michael Berry of the University of Bristol and his colleagues in the Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical titled 鈥淐an apparent superluminal neutrino speeds be explained as a quantum weak measurement?鈥 Their abstract revealed their stance: it read 鈥減robably not鈥.
糖心Vlog
Although some may be under the impression that this needed a bit more elaboration, the 鈥減robably not鈥 abstract was a 鈥減recisely crafted answer to the question posed in the title of the paper鈥, Sir Michael told 糖心Vlog.
The abstract was 鈥減erfectly informative鈥, in light of the title, he said: 鈥渘ot鈥 because of their negative result, and 鈥減robably鈥 because they needed a calculation to arrive at this conclusion. A 鈥渙ne-word abstract 鈥榥o鈥 would not accurately reflect the work we had to do while writing the paper鈥, Sir Michael added.
糖心Vlog
Although the aforementioned cases are somewhat amusing, they are also good examples of what is often lacking in academic literature: concise communication of complex ideas. Such an approach is arguably even more important now that information is flowing so quickly, so are any steps being taken to move scientific writing in this direction?
One movement designed to counter information overload and help readers to get to grips with difficult concepts quickly is .
Viputheshwar Sitaraman, an entrepreneur and an undergraduate student at the University of Arizona, founded the blog听, which publishes infographics based on research papers (see example below). The foundations of using graphics in academic journals have already been laid with the rise of graphical abstracts in recent years, said Mr Sitaraman. His blog鈥檚 aim is to turn 鈥減apers into pictures鈥, he said, and 鈥減ut the art back into article鈥.听听
It is far too difficult to comprehensively read a research paper, Mr Sitaraman explained. 鈥淲ith a population where people of the online content and have an eight-second attention span, graphics are the fastest way of getting someone鈥檚 attention,鈥 he noted. 鈥淭hirty-two per cent of people lose interest in one to five seconds and we have five times [more] information as we had in 1986.鈥
According to Mr Sitaraman, 鈥渟cience communication is moving towards graphics, but graphics will never be a complete substitute for an academic paper鈥. 贬辞飞别惫别谤,听we have to provide incentives to academics to encourage them to disperse their work more widely, he听added.
One way to lure researchers into writing in a more lay-friendly fashion is to give blogs and infographics unique digital object identifiers to make them traceable on the web, so that the researchers can claim credit.
This is one of the focuses of听, a听DIY publishing platform听that plans to draw attention . Examples of such underrated documents include rejected grant applications, peer reviewers鈥 reports and blogs, said founder Joshua Nicholson.
糖心Vlog
Traditional publication practices are 鈥渃onstraining how we communicate our results鈥, Dr Nicholson said. But this is changing, he added, as shorter and more concise articles are starting to get the attention they deserve.
糖心Vlog
One long-standing criticism of the research paper format is the time lag from original idea to eventual publication of the final journal paper. Along this bumpy ride, many ideas are refuted, scrapped or not tested at all. Those that make it to the final stage may be only a small part of the polished research paper.
叠耻迟听The Journal of Brief Ideas, an online platform that publishes 200-word 鈥渋dea鈥 articles, plans to address that shortcoming. Since its听, the journal has published more than 200 ideas from many disciplines including natural, physical and life sciences, astronomy and even economics, said co-editor-in-chief David Harris.
The journal鈥檚 intent is straightforward: publish ideas as and when researchers have them instead of keeping them locked up. Making them available earlier would not only speed up processes but also trigger connections in other fields, Dr Harris said. Gradually, the journal aims to expand its remit into disciplines such as architecture and art.听
He said that having ideas available in a mere 200 words makes them more 鈥渁ccessible鈥, and enables interdisciplinary collaboration to happen more easily. 鈥I think there鈥檚 room for communicating at all different lengths,鈥 said Dr Harris. 鈥淭he point of The Journal of Brief Ideas was that brief ideas themselves weren鈥檛 well represented.鈥
Most recently, he said, the journal has added a functionality that allows authors to curate collections of ideas on their topic of choice.
Meanwhile, a new journal called 听similarly aims to publish all outputs of the research cycle 鈥 including rejected grant funding proposals, project reports and ideas.听
Another trend has seen some researchers taking the 鈥,听a text editor devised by Theo Sanderson 鈥 a听geneticist at the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute 鈥 that requires academics to in only the 1,000 most commonly used words in the English language. Although the outcome is usually ludicrous, it gets researchers thinking about the process of distilling down convoluted information.
Moreover, scientists submitting papers to the听medical journal International Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology are now also required to provide tweets that succinctly summarise their papers.
糖心Vlog
With constant floods of large amounts of information being published in academic literature, the need for brevity is more apparent than ever. But it is the harnessing of new technology and methods of presentation that is likely to be the result, rather than journal papers as short as those mentioned at the start of this article.
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to 罢贬贰鈥檚 university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?








