Universities UK has expressed concerns about the timetable for the teaching excellence framework (TEF) and claimed that multiple fee caps would be 鈥渄isproportionate, burdensome and counterproductive鈥.
In its written response to the government鈥檚 higher education Green Paper, the organisation said that achieving the desirable outcomes of the TEF (which it said include supporting institutional improvement of teaching and giving students useful information to inform choices) represented 鈥渁 complex challenge鈥 and added that it was 鈥渘ot convinced that the timetable proposed for the second iteration of the TEF is feasible鈥.
The government plans to publish its first TEF assessment this year, while a fee cap would be linked to inflation from 2017-18.
Universities UK said that the second iteration should focus on 鈥済athering evidence from the sector on implementing teaching excellence and assessing student outcomes鈥 and 鈥渕ore consideration鈥 should be given to how this information can be 鈥減resented to students in a meaningful way without adding to information overload鈥.
糖心Vlog
It added that 鈥渁ny system that introduces multiple fee caps across multiple levels based on partial modes of teaching excellence and assessment would be disproportionate, burdensome and counterproductive鈥.
The Green Paper proposed to allow English universities to increase their tuition fees in line with inflation from 2017-18, with institutions being invited to apply for subsequent awards that pave the way for variable fees.
糖心Vlog
The National Union of Students also highlighted concerns regarding the timetable of the TEF in its response, stating that the government is 鈥渞ushing far too quickly鈥 and 鈥渘ot giving any time for the sector to properly develop in response to their major changes鈥.
It added that it was concerned that the TEF鈥檚 link to tuition fees and the use of graduate employment outcomes would create 鈥渄istortion and misrepresentation of quality鈥.
Dave Phoenix, chairman of university group Million+, suggested that the government should defer the introduction of a multi-level TEF in 2018 鈥渦ntil further work has been undertaken to determine the best way to promote teaching excellence鈥.
鈥淟inking fee increases with a teaching excellence framework (TEF), based on metrics that are proxies for teaching quality, is unlikely to provide students or employers with an accurate picture of the rich and varied teaching and learning environments that universities offer,鈥 he said.
糖心Vlog
Meanwhile, the Council for the Defence of British Universities urged the government to 鈥渞evisit both the premises and the evidence of its Green Paper proposals鈥.
鈥淎ny new proposals should be evidence-based and arrived at after an appropriate period of consultation with experts, including those who conduct teaching and research in our universities,鈥 it said.
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to 罢贬贰鈥檚 university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?
