糖心Vlog

Will higher education in the 21st century belong to China?

The time is right for Europe's universities to make Chinese connections, say Ka Ho Mok and Jin Jiang

Published on
February 13, 2017
Last updated
February 16, 2017
China flag, chinese

糖心Vlog recently announced in its BRICS and Emerging Economics University Rankings 2017听that India has increased its share of top universities, but China still has the highest density of leading universities in the developing world.

In the BRICS rankings, Chinese universities occupy six of the top 10 positions. There is a growing trend for governments in the Asia and Pacific region to focus on gaining 鈥渨orld-class status鈥 for a few select universities, despite the fact that there is little agreement on how to define a world-class university.

In this context, global rankings are perceived as a zero-sum competition. The table below presents some of the many different schemes adopted by Asian countries to enhance the competitiveness of their selected universities in international rankings. China, like other Asian countries, has made serious efforts to ensure world-class status for its universities.听

Schemes of selected regions in East Asia for world-class university status

Country/Region

Funding Scheme

Mainland China

l听听 Project 985;

l听听 Project 211;

l听听 鈥淒ouble World Class鈥 Project.

Hong Kong

l听听 Comprehensive Education Reviews;

l听听 Role Differentiation Exercise;

l听听 Positioning Hong Kong as International Key Player in High Education;

l听听 University Merging and Deep Collaboration;

l听听 Research Assessment Exercises;

l听听 Teaching and Learning Quality Process Reviews;

l听听 Management Reviews and University Governance Review.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

Taiwan

l听听 Programme for Promoting Academic Excellence of Universities;

l听听 Five Year Excellence Initiative;

l听听 Development Plan for World-class Universities and Research Centres for Excellence.

Japan

l听听 Flagship Universities Project;

l听听 鈥淕lobal 30鈥 Scheme;

l听听 Competitive Funding Allocation Method:

l听 听21st Century Centres of Excellence;

l听 听Global Centres of Excellence;

l听 听World Premier International Research Centre Initiative.

South Korea

l听听 Brain Korea 21;

l听听 World-Class University Initiative;

l听听 Brain Korea 21 Plus Project.

Singapore

l听听 鈥淲orld-Class Universities鈥 Programme.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

Criteria compiled by Jamil Salmi, former coordinator of the World Bank鈥檚 tertiary education programme, measure world-class university status in terms of superior outputs, which include the production of qualified graduates who meet the requirements of the labour market, advanced research publishable by top scientific journals, and effective knowledge transfer in technical innovation and industry.

Using these criteria to measure the performance of China鈥檚 universities, the number ranked in the top 300 has increased from two to 13 over a period of 12 years. The table below shows how six selected public universities in China have steadily climbed the ladder in the 糖心Vlog听rankings and the Academic Ranking of World Universities, produced by Shanghai Jiao Tong University.

Top Chinese (mainland) universities in global rankings

University

糖心Vlog

ARWU

2011/12

2016/17

2012

2016

Tsinghua

71

35

151-200

58

Peking

49

29

151-200

71

UST China

192

153

201-300

101-150

Fudan

226-250

155

201-300

101-150

Jiao Tong

301-350

201-250

151-200

101-150

Zhejiang

301-350

201-250

151-200

101-150

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

To tackle the problem of 鈥渂rain drain鈥 in higher education, the Chinese state has been making great efforts to strengthen talent development. Attracting global talent to universities in mainland China is one of the country鈥檚 crucial strategic plans.

The Changjiang Scholars Programme, established in 1998, is an example of an initiative designed to attract global high-achieving academic scholars (for example, through providing professorships and achievement awards) to enhance the development of Chinese universities.听The total investment in the programme in the first 10 years was approximately RMB454 million (approximately 拢52 million), of which RMB330 million 鈥 more than two thirds 鈥 came from China鈥檚 Ministry of Education.听

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

Chinese dominance and implications for Europe's universities

Given the rise of Chinese universities in global university rankings, will Chinese universities dominate higher education in the 21st听century? The Chinese government has continued its investments in research and knowledge transfer related activities, reflecting the country鈥檚 political will to assert its regional and global leadership in higher education.

Most recently, the Chinese government rolled out the 鈥淒ouble World-class Project鈥, deliberately focusing funding support on selected academic and research fields of studies. This move will enhance the capacity of the selected areas, while the government has actively encouraged local universities to partner with leading universities overseas in promoting research and academic collaborations.

Given time, we would expect Chinese universities to scale new heights in producing internationally referred outputs and asserting world leadership in higher education. In this graph, based on Elsevier鈥檚 Scopus database, THE's John Morgan shows the significant increase of research outputs produced by Chinese scholars, in terms of number of publications, citations and field-weighted citation impact.听

What are the implications of the rise of these Asian universities for the UK and Europe, particularly after Brexit? UK universities should seriously consider branching out to the greater China region, and focus on capturing the opportunities on offer in terms of academic programme development and research collaborations.

European universities should also think seriously about their quality assurance systems and make appropriate changes to cater for the pressing demands of international and transnational higher education in Asia and greater China through forming partnerships in international studies programmes and research collaborations.

As the Chinese government is proactively promoting international collaboration, a number of funding schemes have been introduced to invite leading scholars / institutions overseas to foster collaboration. The rolling out of the 鈥淒ouble World-class Project鈥 will provide strategic investment from the Chinese government to promote inter-university collaboration, not only within the mainland but also internationally. It is vital that universities in Europe do not miss the opportunity to reach out to the Far East to facilitate deeper understanding of this part of the world.

糖心Vlog

ADVERTISEMENT

Professor Ka Ho Mok is vice President and concurrently chair professor of comparative policy of Lingnan University, Hong Kong, and a co-investigator at the Centre for Global 糖心Vlog. Jin Jiang is based in the department of sociology and social policy at Lingnan University, Hong Kong.

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT